In this article
Example H2
Example H3
Example H4
Example H5
Example H6
Enjoying this article?
Share it with the world!

NPS® 101 for Accounting Firms

Post by
November 11, 2024
5 min read

Client retention remains a top challenge for accounting firms. A recent study shows that 36% of accounting firms struggle to keep clients loyal amid rising competition and shifting expectations. Ensuring client satisfaction and loyalty is vital to firm success.

The challenges extend beyond retention. Firms also need to stand out and meet increasingly complex client expectations in a digital-first world. Clients want seamless, hassle-free experiences and consistent, high-quality service.

How can accounting firms ensure they meet these expectations? The first step is understanding client satisfaction levels. One effective tool for this is the Net Promoter Score (NPS®), which measures client loyalty and highlights improvement areas. Simple and widely used, NPS helps firms boost retention, improve reputation, and differentiate their services.

In this article, we’ll cover NPS—what it is, why it’s useful for accounting firms, and how to use it to measure and enhance client satisfaction.

What is NPS? A Primer for Accounting Firms

Even if you’re not familiar with the concept of NPS, you’ve likely participated in an NPS survey.

NPS is a powerful tool for measuring client loyalty. You ask clients one question: “How likely are you to recommend our firm to a friend or colleague?” They respond on a scale from 0 to 10. This quick survey helps gauge satisfaction and identify areas needing improvement.

This quick survey helps you gauge client satisfaction and identify areas for improvement.

However, the true power of the NPS methodology lies in reporting. To calculate NPS, responses to the survey question are divided into three categories:

  • Promoters (9-10): Your most loyal, enthusiastic clients. They're likely to refer new business and remain long-term clients.
  • Passives (7-8): Satisfied but not enthusiastic clients. Competitive offerings might sway them.
  • Detractors (0-6): Unsatisfied clients who may leave and potentially share negative feedback.

Your firm’s NPS “score” is calculated by subtracting the percentage of detractors from the percentage of promoters.

For example, ClearlyRated’s lifetime NPS score is 84%, which is derived from the 86% of promoters across our company survey history minus the 2% detractors across our company survey history. 86% – 2% = 84% NPS.

Importance of NPS for Accounting Firms

Where the competition is high, retaining clients is just as crucial as acquiring new ones, and NPS helps accounting firms understand where they stand in terms of loyalty. It measures how likely clients are to recommend your services, directly affecting your firm's growth.

For instance, Perkins & Co., a Portland-based accounting firm, used NPS to enhance their client services. By identifying areas where clients felt supported and where they saw room for improvement, the firm could make data-driven decisions to elevate their client experience. This approach led them to earn the “Best of Accounting” award, an honor given to firms with exceptional client satisfaction. Perkins & Co. achieved a remarkable NPS score of 84, far exceeding the accounting industry’s average. This accolade has boosted their reputation, attracted referrals, and helped build long-term client relationships.

For accounting firms, where trust and long-term relationships are vital, NPS can highlight hidden pain points. For example, if several clients rate your firm low due to slow response times, it signals the need to improve communication efficiency. By addressing these issues, firms can enhance service quality, boost retention, and increase referrals—leading to more stable revenue streams.

Regular NPS surveys provide a clear view of how clients feel about your services. By acting on this feedback, accounting firms can refine their approach, build stronger relationships, and grow through client loyalty and positive word-of-mouth referrals.

Why Accounting Firms Should Focus on NPS

By prioritizing NPS, companies can effectively gauge client satisfaction, leverage promoters, and make data-driven improvements to their services. 

Here's a detailed breakdown of why accounting firms should focus on NPS:

Client Retention and Growth

A strong NPS directly impacts client retention and future growth. According to recent surveys, 94% of accounting clients are likely to make a referral with their “highly trusted” advisors if asked.​

This highlights the importance of creating a positive experience that leads to word-of-mouth marketing. Promoters are more likely to provide testimonials, which can help both retention and acquisition efforts​.

Furthermore, regular feedback from NPS surveys helps firms identify detractors and areas of improvement This proactive approach allows them to address issues before they lead to client churn. Keeping existing clients satisfied in an industry where relationships are crucial can have long-term financial benefits.

Competitive Edge in a Crowded Market

According to a survey, more than 85% of buyers consider online reviews and ratings as trusted sources when determining whether to engage with a firm​.

Accounting companies can gather positive reviews and testimonials by maintaining high NPS scores. This creates a powerful reputation that differentiates them from competitors. Negative reviews can significantly hurt a firm's credibility, as it takes twice as many positive reviews to reverse the damage caused by just one negative one​.

However, a high NPS can help mitigate this impact. Firms with a strong NPS demonstrate a loyal client base, which can be leveraged in marketing efforts. 

For example, an accounting firm might highlight its NPS score in promotional materials, showcasing it as evidence of client satisfaction and trust. In fact, 72% of respondents say that peer testimonials significantly influence their decision when choosing a firm, and an actionable NPS strategy can fuel this with authentic reviews and referrals​.

This can help reassure potential clients, strengthening the firm’s reputation even in the face of occasional negative feedback.

What is a ‘Good’ NPS Score for an Accounting Firm?

When it comes to NPS, you have a few options for determining what constitutes a “good” score for your firm. 

  • Look at global NPS standards – which categorize 50% NPS as “excellent” and 70% NPS as “world class.” These benchmarks apply across industries and give a general sense of where your firm stands.
  • Compare your NPS score to others within the accounting industry. For instance, the 2023 Accounting Industry NPS Benchmark sits at 41%, which gives you an idea of the average. Notably, service leaders—those recognized as 2023 Best of Accounting award winners—achieved an average NPS score of 81%. This difference illustrates the gap between average firms and top performers in the industry.
  • Look to service leaders across industries. While broader industry comparisons can be helpful, it’s important to focus on your own accounting firm’s trends over time. Regularly measuring and improving your NPS can ensure you're not just meeting industry standards but pushing toward becoming a service leader.

How to Implement NPS in Accounting Firms

For accounting firms, implementing NPS can be a game-changer. It offers a straightforward way to capture client feedback, uncover valuable insights, and enhance service delivery. By acting on the data gathered, firms can make targeted improvements that boost client satisfaction and foster long-term loyalty. 

And when clients are loyal, the impact extends beyond improved relationships—firms can see higher retention rates, increased referrals, and ultimately, revenue growth.

Here's how you can implement NPS in your accounting firm:

Setting up NPS Surveys

An effective NPS survey consists of two key elements:

  • The core question: "On a scale of 0-10, how likely are you to recommend our firm to a friend or colleague?"
  • An open-ended follow-up: "What's the primary reason for your score?"

This combination provides quantitative data and qualitative insights crucial for understanding client sentiment.

Choose a survey tool that integrates with your firm's existing systems and automates follow-ups. Integrate survey data with your CRM to track responses over time, identifying trends that inform service improvements.

Choosing the Right Time to Send Surveys

Timing is crucial for obtaining actionable feedback. For accounting firms, optimal survey moments include:

  • After completing a tax return
  • Upon finalizing an audit
  • Following the conclusion of a consulting engagement

For ongoing client relationships, consider quarterly or bi-annual surveys to monitor long-term satisfaction without causing survey fatigue.

Analyzing NPS Data for Accounting Firms

Once you’ve collected NPS survey responses, the next step is to make sense of the data. 

Interpreting the Scores

While we've covered the basics of Promoters (9-10), Passives (7-8), and Detractors (0-6), the key lies in understanding the implications for your firm:

  • Promoters: Focus on what delights these clients and replicate it across your practice.
  • Passives: Identify what's preventing them from becoming promoters. Often, small improvements can make a big difference.
  • Detractors: Prioritize addressing their concerns to prevent client churn and negative word-of-mouth.

Remember, your NPS is the percentage of Promoters minus the percentage of Detractors.

Segment Your Analysis

Break down NPS data by:

  • Service lines (tax, audit, advisory)
  • Client size or industry
  • Partner or team handling the account

This segmentation can reveal areas of excellence or concern within specific parts of your practice.

Identify Patterns in Feedback

Look for recurring themes in the open-ended responses. For accounting firms, common areas might include:

  • Timeliness of deliverables
  • Clarity of financial explanations
  • Proactivity in tax planning or financial advice

Understanding these patterns helps prioritize improvement efforts.

Correlate NPS with Financial Metrics

Link NPS data to financial outcomes such as:

  • Client retention rates
  • Revenue per client
  • Referral business generated

This correlation can demonstrate the tangible impact of client satisfaction on your firm's bottom line.

💡 Pro Tip: Establish a regular review process where partners and team leads discuss NPS. 

Pairing NPS data with other metrics like customer lifetime value (CLV) or client churn rates can provide a more holistic view of client loyalty and retention efforts.

Improving NPS Scores in Accounting Firms

Now that you’ve gathered your NPS data and analyzed it, the next step is to take action to improve your score. 

Here’s how accounting firms can respond effectively and ensure feedback drives positive change:

Responding to Promoters

Engaging with feedback—both positive and negative—is critical for improving your NPS score. 

When you receive praise from Promoters, it’s a great opportunity to strengthen relationships. A simple “thank you” goes a long way, but you can also take it further by asking them for testimonials or referrals.

These satisfied clients are your best advocates, and their recommendations can help attract new clients.

Addressing Detractor Feedback

Detractors, on the other hand, provide the most critical feedback, and this is where you can make the most impact. 

For example, the Detractor might leave a harsh comment, such as, "I’ve been frustrated with your customer service team’s lack of availability during critical moments of the tax season." This client is at risk of leaving your accounting firm unless you address their concerns quickly.

Reaching out to dissatisfied clients directly to resolve their concerns not only helps turn their experience around but also shows that your firm values client relationships.

Personalized responses that acknowledge their pain points—whether it’s service delays or communication breakdowns—help rebuild trust. Swift follow-ups and showing a genuine willingness to improve can potentially turn a Detractor into a Promoter over time.

Implementing Systemic Changes

Improving your NPS score isn’t just about reacting to individual feedback—it’s about implementing systemic changes that prioritize client needs. 

For instance, if multiple clients mention slow response times or inefficient processes, it may signal the need to improve your internal processes. This could involve implementing more efficient communication tools or adopting new technology to enhance service delivery. 

Additionally, you can offer more personalized services or flexible billing options to make clients feel heard and appreciated. These systemic changes help improve your service delivery and ensure your firm adapts to evolving client expectations. 

Real-Life Examples/ Case Studies of NPS in Accounting Firms

Let’s explore some real-life cases where firms leveraged NPS to improve client relationships, boost retention, and drive growth.

1. American Express Credit Cards

With an impressive NPS of 32, it’s clear that American Express is doing something right. A big part of their success comes from positive interactions and excellent customer service, which really makes cardholders feel valued.

Their generous rewards program adds even more appeal, showing customers they’re getting a great deal. This approach has effectively discouraged account switching, as many prefer to stay with American Express rather than chase after introductory offers elsewhere.

Derek Martin, the director of global consumer card sales at American Express, emphasized in an interview that NPS isn't just a superficial measure. Instead, it plays a crucial role in driving significant improvements in customer experience and positively impacting the company's bottom line.

“People who say you can’t correlate the data to actual revenue items—it’s not true, at least not in my case,” says Martin. “I can show you data that says that as Net Promoter Score rises, customers spend more money, they’re more loyal, they’re putting more dollars on an American Express card, and they’re leaving us less.” — Source

2. Perkins & Co. + ClearlyRated

At Perkins & Co., the leaders recognized how crucial good data is for an accounting firm. 

However, until 2011, they didn’t track any metrics related to their service performance. Their client satisfaction data was inconsistent, mainly coming from casual chats with clients. This created a bias, as they usually engaged with clients they already had strong relationships with. 

Furthermore, without service benchmarks from the accounting industry, they couldn't accurately gauge how they compared to competitors.

It soon became evident that they needed a genuine understanding of their service leaders’ relationships with clients. They required a way to verify their assumptions rather than just relying on gut feelings.

By leveraging NPS, Perkins & Co. gathered quantifiable data and anecdotal feedback that helped them refine their client service approach. They used this feedback to improve internal processes, enhance their communication standards across the firm, and celebrate service wins through ClearlyRated's "shout-out" feature. 

The firm has also used positive client testimonials from the NPS process to support its marketing efforts. Their dedication to client feedback through NPS earned them ClearlyRated's "Best of Accounting" award for multiple years, highlighting their commitment to excellent service.

Moreover, they are also the first-ever ClearlyRated Best of Accounting 10-Year Diamond Winner for client satisfaction.

Read the entire case study here.

Why Does NPS Work?

NPS works because of the following reasons:

  • It’s simple. Because it’s a single metric, NPS is easy to measure, track over time, and use to benchmark your firm’s client satisfaction and service quality against the rest of the industry.
  • NPS is a data-driven approach that relies on insights directly from the client. The concise format of the survey allows you to focus on the information that really matters while taking the guesswork out of assessing how your clients feel about you.
  • Time is everything (it’s short!). People tend to turn and run when they see long surveys. And as much as your clients are ready and willing to provide you with feedback – they are protective of their time.
  • It promotes transparency. By quantifying intangible concepts like client satisfaction and service quality, NPS provides accounting firms with a singular metric to weigh performance, set improvement goals, and rally the team around. When everyone in the organization clearly understands how their behavior can inform NPS, they’ll begin to obsess over client satisfaction and service quality as a practice and a philosophy.

Check out the best NPS software to capture and understand your customers’ loyalty towards your brand!

How to Encourage Clients to Participate in NPS Surveys

To enhance participation in NPS surveys, it’s essential to create a seamless experience for clients, making their engagement as effortless as possible.

Simplifying the Process for Clients

According to research, surveys that are concise tend to yield higher response rates. This makes it crucial to keep surveys short and straightforward. To enhance participation, utilize digital platforms that simplify client engagement.

Tools like email and SMS not only offer quick access to surveys but also cater to the on-the-go nature of clients today.  

In fact, mobile-optimized surveys can be completed 30-40% faster than those designed for desktop use. This approach not only increases convenience but also maximizes the likelihood of receiving timely feedback.

Offering Incentives for Feedback

An incentive could be anything from a small discount on future services to entry into a prize draw. 

Research indicates that incentives can significantly increase survey completion rates. Moreover, a study published by Giftogram indicates that incentivizing participation can increase response rates beyond 20%.

Similarly, encourage clients to share their feedback by clearly communicating how their input can enhance your services. By framing participation as a way for clients to help shape their own experiences, you foster a sense of involvement and ownership in the process. 

Using NPS to Attract New Clients

Attracting new clients requires more than just traditional marketing tactics, and leveraging NPS is a powerful way to do just that. Here’s how accounting firms can showcase their strengths and build credibility with potential clients:

Marketing with Positive NPS Scores

When you showcase your firm’s NPS, it sends a clear message to potential clients about your commitment to customer satisfaction. Accounting firms can effectively incorporate their NPS into marketing materials, such as brochures, websites, and social media posts, to emphasize their dedication to delivering exceptional service.

For example, including your NPS score in a prominent position on your website can reassure prospective clients of your reliability and quality. Research shows that businesses with high NPS scores often enjoy a reputation for reliability and quality, attracting new clients looking for trustworthy service providers.

Additionally, displaying testimonials from satisfied clients alongside NPS scores can create a compelling narrative that enhances your firm’s credibility.

Building Trust Through Transparency

Transparency is crucial in establishing trust with potential clients, and sharing your NPS publicly reflects that openness. 

When clients see that you are willing to discuss both your strengths and areas for improvement, it builds confidence in your ability to meet their needs. 

By openly discussing your NPS results, you demonstrate accountability and position your firm as a proactive player in the industry. This level of trust can significantly influence a prospective client's decision-making process, ultimately paving the way for new business opportunities.

Leverage ClearlyRated as a Solution for Accounting Firms

As we saw above, understanding client satisfaction through NPS can provide invaluable insights that shape business strategies and improve service offerings. By collecting and analyzing this feedback, firms can enhance client relationships, boost retention rates, and attract new clients.

If you’re ready to enhance your client feedback initiatives, ClearlyRated offers tailored solutions for accounting firms.

It enables accounting firms to create NPS surveys and questions, set up follow-ups, and collect detailed responses, providing clear insights into client sentiment.

Our veteran team of survey experts has compiled a Satisfaction Survey Checklist specifically for accounting firms to ensure your client survey initiative is successful. This resource will help you avoid common pitfalls and build a roadmap for your survey efforts.

Moreover, ClearlyRated offers comprehensive analytics and benchmarking features, allowing firms to track their NPS against industry standards. You can access valuable resources, including the latest benchmarks for the accounting industry, to see how your firm stacks up against competitors.

So why wait? Book a free demo with ClearlyRated and get started today!

Stay updated, subscribe today!

By providing this information, you agree to allow ClearlyRated to store and process the personal data in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Send your first survey with ClearlyRated!
No items found.

Resources that elevate your efforts